Department of Endodontology

Temple University

 

 

 

 

December 04

December03

 

December01

 

 

Current

November 04

November03

November02

November01

March01

December00

November 05

October04

October03

October 02

October01

February01

November00

October 05

September04

September03

September02

September01

January01

October00

 

 

 

Week of September 14, 2005

 

 

 

 

Title: A comparison of spreader penetration depth and load required during lateral condensation in teeth prepared using various root canal preparation techniques

 

Author: Dulaimi, SF et al

 

Journal: International Endodontic Journal, Vol.38, No. 8, p 510, August 2005

 

Purpose: To compare the influence of various root canal preparation techniques on spreader penetration depth and load required during lateral condensation with gutta percha and sealer

 

Reviewer: Brian Chang, DDS

 

Methods and Materials:

  • 80 extracted teeth with single straight canals were used
  • They were divided into 4 groups of twenty using 4 different instrumentation techniques
    • Step-back without gates glidden
    • Step-back with gates glidden
    • Crown down pressureless technique
    • Hybrid technique (step-down / step-back)
  • A simulated periodontal ligament was fabricated from a uniform layer of silicon impression material
  • The roots were mounted in acrylic resin to simulate a tooth socket
  • All canals were prepared to size 35-40 apically
  • A master gutta percha cone coated with sealer was placed to working length
  • The Instron® testing machine applied a load parallel to the long axis of the acrylic block with the stainless steel hand spreader of the same size as the master apical file. This was done until the spreader stopped entering the canal and the load was recorded
  • An accessory cone was placed and the distance of this cone from the working length was recorded

 

Results:

  • Canals shaped by the crown down pressure less technique had the lowest mean spreader load (1.31 kg), while the step-back without gates had the highest value (1.615 kg). The differences in loads were NOT statistically significant.
  • Step-back technique with gates glidden had the least difference between spreader penetration and the working length (1.925 mm), with the greatest difference coming from the crown down pressure less technique (4.75 mm). The differences in spreader penetration depth WERE statistically significant

 

Discussion:

            The canal preparation technique is an important factor that seems to affect the depth of initial spreader penetration, and ultimately the quality of the apical seal.

 

 

 

 

Title: In vitro antimicrobial activity of Fill Canal, Sealapex, Mineral Trioxide Aggregate, Portland cement and EndoRez

 

Author: Sipert, CR, et al.

 

Journal: IEJ, Vol. 38, No. 8 (p539-543), Aug. 2005.

 

Reviewer: Brian S. Jeon, DMD

 

Purpose: To determine in vitro the antimicrobial activity of Fill Canal (ZOE-based), Sealapex (Ca(OH)2-based), MTA, Portland cement and EndoRez (containing methacrylate) on various species of microorganisms.

 

Methods and Materials:

  • The base layer of agar was poured into Petri plates.
  • In each plate, five wells were prepared and filled with sealers/cements.
  • 7 different microorganisms were grown separately and seeded into agar, which was used as the second layer of the plate.
  • A total number of 22 plates were prepared: 3 plates of each microorganism and one plate w/o strain seeding.
  • The zones of inhibition were measured after 24 hr incubation.

 

 Results/Conclusion:

  • Fill Canal, Sealapex, MTA and Portland cement all showed evidence of inhibition.
  • EndoRez did not demonstrate antimicrobial activity.
  • The strain of E.coli was not inhibited by MTA and Portland cement, whereas Fill Canal and Sealapex inhibited the growth of all tested strains.

 

 

 

Title: Vital pulp therapy with mineral trioxide aggregate

 

Author: Karabucak et al

 

Journal: Dental Traumatology 2005; 21: 240-243

 

Reviewer: Alex Wang, DDS

 

Purpose: To describe two case reports of treatments of complicated crown fracture using MTA as pulp capping material.

 

Case 1:

- 9 y/o male with traumatic injury to tooth #9 causing horizontal mid-crown fracture with small pulp exposure

- trauma occurred two days prior

- Pt complained of mild pain to cold, not spontaneous

- tooth tested percussion sensitive and severe but not lingering pain to cold

- tooth had an immature apex

- treatment procedure:

                     - removing 2mm of pulp tissue from the exposure site

                     - control hemorrhage

                     - MTA was placed to cover the exposed pulp

                     - place ZOE as temporary filling

- follow up 3 days later with mild cold and percussion sensitivity

- subsequent follow ups showed continuing apical root development and pulp vitality

 

Case 2:

- 9 y/o girl with traumatic injury to teeth #8 causing horizontal mid-crown fracture with pulp exposure

- trauma occurred the same day

- tooth was sensitive to palpation and percussion with 2+ mobility and no response to cold nor EPT

- tooth had an immature apex

- treatment procedure is same as above

- subsequent follow-ups showed continuing apical root development and pulp vitality

 

Conclusion: MTA can be used as pulp capping material in treating complicated crown fracture with pulp exposures.

 

 

 

 

Week of September 21, 2005

 

 

 

Title: Susceptibility of a polycaprolactone-based root canal filling material to degradation.  I. alkaline hydrolysis.

 

Author: Tay FR, et al

 

Journal: JOE, Vol. 31(8)593-598, August 2005

 

Reviewer: Kevin Axx, DDS

 

Purpose: To examine the degradability of Resilon™ after alkaline treatment using gutta percha as the control material.

 

Introduction: Gutta percha is a relatively inert material, but most biodegradable aliphatic polyesters (such as Resilon™) are known to be hydrolyzed by enzymes and alkalis, via surface or bulk erosion that commence from the amorphous regions of these semi-crystalline polymers. 

 

Materials & Methods:

·        Resilon™ pellets and Obtura gutta percha pellets were molded into standardized disks

·        Alkaline hydrolysis solution was made using 50g NaOH pellets and 500mL ethanol

·        Resilon™ and gutta percha were divided into 3 groups

            Group 1: immersed in 50% ethanol, 60 min (control – no alkaline tx)

            Group 2: immersed in 20% sodium ethoxide, 20min

            Group 3: immersed in 20% sodium ethoxide, 60min

·        Samples were examined using Field-Emission SEM, and conventional TEM.

 

Results:

·        All disks in Grp 1 appeared smooth revealing only the polymer component.

·        Resilon™ in Grp 2 showed evidence of fissures along the material surface with the particulate nature of the filled polymer vaguely revealed. 

·        The two types of filler particles could be clearly seen in Grp 3: finer less electron dense bismuth oxychloride particles, and larger sparser silicate glass particles

·        Obtura gutta percha disks were minimally susceptible to alkaline hydrolysis.

 

Conclusions:  The results of the study show that there is a difference in the susceptibility of a polycaprolactone-based and a polyisoprene-based root filling material to alkaline hydrolysis.  Since both alkaline and enzymatic hydrolysis proceed via cleavage of the ester bonds in the aliphatic polyester, further investigation is necessary to determine if Resilon™ can be enzymatically degraded in vivo and serve as a source of nourishment to the anaerobic flora known to exist in the root canal system. 

 

 

 

 

Title: Effect of root canal filling/sealer systems on apical endotoxin penetration: a coronal leakage evaluation.

 

Journal:  JOE  31(8): 599-604

 

Author: E. Williamson, et al.

 

Reviewed by: Ada L. Greenfield, DMD

 

Purpose: To evaluate the magnitude of endotoxin penetration through root canal treated teeth using a dual chamber model system.

 

Materials and Methods: Forty-Four maxillary anterior teeth were prepared endodontically  and canals filled   either by lateral condensation  (LC) or a warm thermoplasticized  technique (WTT) in combination with either Roth’s 801 or AH 26 sealers.  Teeth were suspended in the model system with a mixed anaerobic bacterial suspension in the upper chamber and HBSS in the lower chamber. The QCL-1000 LAL assay was used to measure endotoxin at 0, 1, 7, 14, and 21 days. Four groups of teeth were compared statistically,   two with Roth’s 801 sealer (LC and WTT) and two with  AH 26 sealer (LC and WTT).

 

Results:  The canals filled by LC in combination with Roth’s 801 sealer permitted the least endotoxin penetration and data suggested that Roth’s 801 sealer, with the slowest setting rate, may inhibit endotoxin penetration. The canals filled by LC in combination with AH 26 sealer exhibited the most endotoxin leakage over time, followed by the WTT/AH 26 group and the WTT/ Roth’s 801.

 


 

 

 

Title: Essential elements of evidenced-based endodontics:  Steps involved in conducting clinical research

 

Author: Torabinejad, M et al

 

Journal: JOE, Vol. 31(8) 563, August 2005

 

Reviewer:  Dan Bitner, DMD

 

Purpose: To describe the concepts of evidence-based practice, the process of systematic reviews and their implications on the future of endodontic practice.

 

Steps involved in performing a systematic review:

  • Asking specific clinical questions
  • Conducting efficient searches to find pertinent literature
  • Critically appraising the found literature
  • Identifying the gaps in knowledge
  • Conducting research wherever it is needed
  • Incorporating the results of research into the clinical practice
  • Evaluating the effect of incorporated changes on healthcare outcomes

Systematic reviews versus literature reviews:

  • Systematic reviews are a synopsis of the existing evidence on a specific topic which concentrates on a very specific and narrow, clinically relevant question
  • Literature review covers various aspects of a clinical or non clinical subject

Types of Studies:

  • Experimental studies
    • Uncontrolled studies provide very weak evidence and should not be used    to guide practice
    • Controlled studies can be in the form of randomized clinical, field or community trials
  • Observational studies include:
    • Cohort Studies follow an exposed cohort compared to an unexposed cohort to determine the incidence of a given outcome.
    • Case control studies: when cases with a particular outcome and controls that do not have the same outcome are first selected, and the exposure assessment is done retrospectively
    • Cross sectional and ecological studies assess the relationship of a particular disease with an exposure at the same time.  They can give relationships between exposure and outcome.
    • Case report and case series represent the first clues of a new disease or adverse effect of exposures.

Level of Evidence:

·         Level 1: Randomized controlled trial

·         Level 2: low level RCT, cohort studies and systematic reviews of cohort studies

·         Level 3: case control and systematic reviews of case control

·         Level 4: low level cohort and case series

·         Level 5: case reports, expert opinion and literature reviews

 

Discussion:

Despite endodontic excellent success rates in saving natural teeth, research projects at the highest levels of evidence should be conducted to strengthen the current data

 

 

 

 

 

 

Title: An in vitro evaluation of the cytotoxicity of various endodontic irrigants on human gingival fibroblasts

 

Author:  Barnhart B. et al.

 

Journal:  JOE, Vol: 31, (8), Aug. 2005

 

Reviewer:  Brian Stein, DMD

 

Purpose:  To measure the cytotoxicity of five endodontic irrigants at various concentrations on cultured human gingival fibroblasts (hGF)

 

Materials and Methods:  hGF were grown in Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM).  Ninty-six – well plastic tissue culture plates, w/ 200 µl of DMEM containing 2x104 hGF in each.  200 µl of each irrigant at predetermined concentration with an exposure time of 15 min. (represent clinical situation) was tested.  Five experimental groups were used:

 

(1)   saturated Ca(OH)2 

(2)   2% IKI 

(3)   5.25% NaOCl 

(4)   7.5% Betadine scrub (BS) 

(5)   28% stabilized chlorine dioxide (SCD)

 

Positive control - DMEM (18 wells tested).  Irrigants were tested in dose-response manner, starting at highest concentration and continuing w/ five dilutions.  Six wells were tested for each concentration of each irrigant, experiment was repeated two times. Cell number was quantified using CyQUANT Cell Proliferation Assay Kit:

 

-         used to estimate the LD50 for each irrigant

-         LD50 = lowest concentration of each test irrigant necessary to produce 50% lethality of hGFs when compared to controls

-         dilution coefficient: logarithmic difference between clinical concentration and LD50 of irrrigant

 

Results:  A lower dilution coefficient is indicative of a less toxic irrigant.

 

·        BS was significantly more toxic than all others

·        NaOCl was significantly more toxic than SCD, Ca(OH)2, and IKI

·        SCD was significantly more toxic than Ca(OH)2 and IKI

·        No significant difference between Ca(OH)2 and IKI

·        Significant difference among intra-group concentrations for all irrigants

 

Discussion:     CyQUANT assay is non-radioactive assay that provides the potential to evaluate toxicity in terms of cell proliferation (rapid method, does not rely on cellular metabolic activity).

 

·        Results demonstrated IKI and Ca(OH)2 were the least toxic irrigants tested with SCD appearing slightly more toxic.

·        2% IKI and 10% Ca(OH)2 are relatively nontoxic alternatives for irrigation.

·        2% IKI has superior antimicrobial properties.

 

 

 

 

Title:  Biocompatibility in vitro tests of mineral trioxide aggregate and regular and white portland cements

 

Author:  Ribeiro, D et al

 

Journal:  JOE Vol. 31, (8),  August 2005

 

Reviewer: Brian Chang, DDS

 

Purpose: To test biocompatibility concerning genotoxicity and cytotoxicity of mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) and Portland cement

 

Methods and Materials:

  • Mouse lymphoma cells were cultivated. The cell suspension was counted and seeded on a plate at a density of 1 X 104 ­­­cells.
  • MTA and Portland cement were prepared in increasing concentrations from 1μg to 1000μg.
  • The negative control was treated with vehicle control (PBS) and the positive control was treated with methyl metasulfonate (MMS).
  • After incubating, for 3 hr at 37o C the cells were centrifuged at 1000 rpm for 5 min and washed 3x with fresh medium and responded in fresh medium. Each individual treatment was repeated three times.
  • Cytotoxicity was performed using Trypan blue staining after treatment. Non viable cells stained blue and observation was under a slide cover and microscope.
  • Electrophoresis along with an automated analysis system was used to estimate DNA damage to the cells. Tail moment (product of tail DNA/total DNA by center of gravity) was considered to estimate DNA damage.

 

Results:

  • No primary DNA damage was observed after cell exposure to MTA and Portland cements.
  • MTA and Portland cement associated cell mortality was <15%.

 

Discussion:  These results indicate that MTA and Portland cements had no statistically significant cytotoxic effects in mouse lymphoma cells. These materials also did not induce DNA damage. MTA and Portland cement may be safe in use in dental practice.

 

 

 

 

 

 

To Top


Temple University School of Dentistry. All contents copyright (C) 1996. All rights reserved.
Created: September 20, 2000 Revised: URL:

 

Roy H. Stevens, DDS, MS; Wanda Gordon, D.M.D. - Comments to author:

wgordon@dental.temple.edu

Questions or problems regarding this page? Please mail:

webmaster@dental.temple.edu