Department of Endodontology

Temple University

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Current 

December 04

December03

December02

 

 

 

November 05

November04

November03

November02

December01

March01

December00

October 05

October 04

October03

October02

November01

February01

November00

September 05

September 04

September03

September02

September01

January01

October00

 

 

Week of October 1, 2001

 

 

 

Title:  Control of microorganisms in vitro by calcium hydroxide pastes

Journal: International Endodontic Journal: 34(5): 341-345, July 2001

Author: Estrela, C. et al.

Prepared by: Lance Isaac, D.M.D.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine the influence of vehicles on the antimicrobial action of calcium hydroxide.

Materials and Methods: A total of 588,  size 50,  sterile absorbent paper points were immersed in various microbial suspensions for 3 minutes. The points were then placed on Petri dishes and covered with intracanal dressings containing calcium hydroxide: Ca(OH)2 + saline; Ca(OH)2 + camphorated para-monochlorophenol; Ca(OH)2 + 1% chlorhexidine solution; Ca(OH)2 + 3% sodium lauryl sulphate; Ca(OH)2 + Otosporin.
After 1min, 48 and 72h and 7d, 147 absorbent paper cones were removed from contact with the intracanal dressings and individually transported and immersed in 5mL of Letheen Broth, followed by incubation at 37° C for 48h. Microbial growth was evaluated by turbidity of the culture medium.
A 0.1mL inoculum obtained from the Letheen Broth was transferred to 5mL of BHI, and incubated at 37° C for 48h. Bacterial growth was again evaluated by turbidity of the culture medium.
Positive BHI tubes were selected and inocula were spread on the surface of BHI agar and incubated at 37° C of 48h. Gram staining of the BHI growth and from colonies growing on BHI agar was carried out.

Results: An antimicrobial effect occurred after 48h on the cultures of S. mutans, E. faecalis, S. aureus, P. aeruginosa, B. subtilis, C. albicans and a mixed culture, irrespective of the intracanal dressing.

Conclusion: Under the conditions of this study, the various vehicles associated with calcium hydroxide pastes did not influence the time required for microbial inactivation.

 

 

 


Title:
Cyclic fatigue of ProFile rotary instruments after prolonged clinical use.

Author: Gambarini G.

Journal: Inter. Endo. J.:34(5):386, July 2001

Reviewer: Pranav Vohra, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate resistance to cyclic fatigue of new and used (after 10 clinical cases) ProFile NiTi rotary instruments.

Materials & Methods:  30 ProFile instruments for each of the following sizes ( .06-25, .06-20, .04-20, .04-15) were selected for study and divided into GROUP A: 10 new instruments, GROUP B: 20 used instruments.

-Group B instruments were used in 10 teeth (6 - 7 curved molars, 3 - 4 single rooted teeth: avg.: 26.7 canals) at 250 rpm with irrigation and Crown Down Technique. Instruments that showed irreversible damage were discarded.

-To test cyclic fatigue, group A and group B instruments were then allowed to rotate freely in a stainless steel artificial canal at 350 rpm while simulating clinical conditions. Instruments were kept cool during rotation with an air spray to prevent overheating.

-Instruments were rotated until fracture occurred and the time to fracture was visually noted using a chronometer.

Results:

1.      In all sizes, new instruments were statistically (two sample t-test, P<.01) more resistant to fracture than used instruments.

2.      No instruments, new or used, underwent intracanal failure during the test period.

3.      Larger instruments failed in less time under dynamic stress than smaller instruments.

4.      .04 tapered instruments were more resistant to fracture than .06 tapered instruments of the same tip         diameter.

Discussion: Prolonged clinical use reduces cyclic fatigue resistance of NiTi rotary instruments.

-Each rotary instrument can be used in up to 10 clinical cases without intracanal failure.

- If torque is higher than the elastic limit of the instrument, plastic deformation/ fracture can occur easily (stresses passive instrumentation and continuous in-out movement.)

 

 

 


Title: A methodology for quantitative evaluation of root canal instrumentation using microcomputed tomography

Author: L. Bergmans

Journal: International Endodontic Journal, 34(5): 390—398, 2001

Prepared by: Greg Dearing, D.M.D.

Purpose: To present an objective methodology for quantitative evaluation of root canal instrumentation using microcomputer tomography, together with developed software based on a constructed mathematical model.

Materials and Methods:

  • A desktop X-ray micro CT scanner was used to provide data sets of a periodontally involved extracted mandibular molar before and after instrumentation utilizing the profile 0.04 taper instruments, which were stored for later use by software.
  • A volume visualization package was applied to obtain 3-D renderings of the molar to illustrate the qualitative visualization capacity.
  • Next, medical image volume fusion software was used to allow alignment of pre and post image volumes.
  • Finally, software was developed to make quantitative measurements and to provide additional qualitative information on the registered image volumes.
  • This procedure implemented a true 3-D mathematical model for quantification of instrumentation effects.
  • Using a local co-ordinate frame, perpendicular reslices were made at 5 different levels within the mesio-buccal canal to evaluate transportation and centering ability.

Results:

  • At first accurate and detailed 3-D renderings were obtained.
  • The general and local canal shape before and after preparation could visually be examined in 360 degrees rotation.
  • Numerical values were obtained for volume, volume changes, and transportation.
  • Centering ability was calculated by centering ratio and center movement.

Conclusions:

  • This methodology is a new and objective way for quantitative evaluation of root canal instrumentation using micro-computer tomography and dedicated software.

 

To Top

 

Week of October 8, 2001

 

 


Title: The histological effects of four endodontic sealers implanted in the oral mucosal: submucous injection versus implant in polyethylene tubes

Author: J.A.P. Figueiredo, Pesce, et al.

Journal: Inter. Endo. J.: 34(5): 377, July 2001

Prepared By: Alison Morrison, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate the creation of pigmentation and the histological response to four endodontic sealers implanted in the oral mucosal of rabbits, either by submucous injection or implantation within polyethylene tubes.

Materials and Methods: Thirty white female New Zealand rabbits with similar weights and taken from the same breeder were randomly divided into four groups. One type of sealer was assessed in each group.

Sealer #1 (eight rabbits) N-Rickert precipitated silver, 30.0 gms (30%)

Sealer#2 (eight rabbits) AH-26, silver (10%)

Sealer#3 (seven rabbits) Fillcanal

Sealer#4 (seven rabbits) Sealer 26

The introduction of sealer into each rabbit was carried out in one of two ways: by submucous injection or implantation in polyethylene tubes with a small portion of cement forced out of the tube, thus simulating a common clinical situation. The location of placement (0.1mL) in each rabbit corresponds in humans to the superior gingivo-labial sulcus. Observation took place after 30, 60, and 90 days. After 90 days, the rabbits were sacrificed and the maxillae removed.

Results:

  1. Fillcanal and Sealer 26 did not induce the formation of tattoos in any specimens (they contain no silver).
  2. At the 60 and 90-day observations, N-Rickert and AH-26 presented mucosal tattoos.
  3. N-Rickert induced the greatest number and largest tattoos.
  4. A longer period of contact did not generate a greater number of tattoos; it only affected the size of the tattoo generated.
  5. On histological analysis, no differences were found between the two methods of implantation.
  6. All sealers elicited some kind of inflammatory response with the most irritating sealer being Fillcanal followed by N-Rickert and AH-26. Sealer 26 elicited only mild reaction.

Conclusion: The hypothesis that the presence of silver in the chemical composition of the sealer could tattoo the mucosal was proven. There was not only a greater number of tattoos with N-Rikert sealer, which also has a higher concentration of silver, but also, the size of these was greater than those observed with AH-26 which has a lower concentration of silver. For clinical practice, one can infer that the bigger the overflow of sealer material, the greater the risk of tattoo formation. In 1978, the silver powder in AH-26 was replaced with calcium hydroxide to form an additional sealer, Sealer-26, which is less irritating to tissues. Both sealers are used because there is still some debate about their other physical and chemical characteristics.

 

 


Title: Methodological consideration in the determination of the working length

Author: M.A. Martinez-Lozano, et al.

Journal: International Endodontic Journal, 34(5):371-376, July 2001

Prepared by: Donna Salin, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate the diagnostic efficacy of an electronic system for the determination of working length, in comparison with two radiological methods (conventional film and digital radiography).

Materials and Methods:

  • The study sample consisted of 28 root canals belonging to 20 human mandibular teeth.
  • The pulp chambers were accessed and the root canals located. Using the electronic locator, 15 size files were inserted until the needle approached the red ‘apex’ mark of the dial, at which point, the file was stopped and immobilized by applying cyanoacrylate within the chamber opening.
  • Conventional and digitized images were then obtained of each specimen, which were used to determine the maximum radiographic length and the distance from the file tip to the radiographic apex.
  • The actual file position was determined by apical grinding, making it possible to observe the relation between the file tip and the apical foramen and anatomical apex.
  • Using a Nikon surface light microscope, measurements were made between the file tip and the anatomical apex as well as between the file tip and the apical foramen.
  • A comparison was made between the working length measurements obtained by the two radiological methods (conventional and digital) and the apex locator, using as gold standard the observation of the file position within the root following selective grinding of the root tissue.

Results:

  • The electronic method was satisfactory in 67.8% of the cases (within ± 0.5 mm of the apical foramen), versus 50.6 % and 61.4% for the conventional and digital radiological methods, respectively.
  • Comparisons of all distances measured are seen in Table 2 and Table 3 (pg. 374 & 375).
  • No statistically significant differences occurred between the techniques used according to the chi-squared and Kruskal-Wallis nonparametric tests.

Conclusions:

  • None of the techniques was totally satisfactory in establishing the true working length.
  • There were no differences between the techniques investigated.

 

 


Title: Apical extrusion of debris and irrigants using two hand and three engine-driven instrumentation techniques

Author: Ferraz, C., Gomes, N., Gomes, B., et al

Journal: Inter. Endo J 34(5):354-358, July 2001

Key Words: apical extrusion, endodontics, engine-driven techniques, manual techniques

Reviewed by: M. Pallante, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate the weight of debris and irrigant volume extruded apically in vitro using extracted teeth.

Materials and Methods:  In this study 5 groups of 20 extracted human teeth with single canals of similar length and shape with curvatures from 1-10° were instrumented using one of the following five techniques:

  1. Balanced Force Technique
  2. Hybrid
  3. Quantec 2000
  4. Profile .04
  5. Pow-R

Debris extruded from the apical foramen were collected in preweighed 1.5 ml tubes. The volume of this fluid was determined using visual comparison to control tubes filled with successive .25 ml increments of distilled water. The weight of dried extruded dentin debris was also calculated. All results were analyzed statistically using the Kruskal-Wallis nonparametric test to determine is significant differences existed among the groups (P<.05)

Results:  No significant differences in volume of irrigant or quantity of debris existed among the engine driven techniques. However, the balanced force technique extruded significantly smaller amounts of irrigant and debris than the hybrid technique. The performance f the balanced force technique was similar to those of Ni-Ti rotary files.

Discussion:  Apical extrusion is important clinically when considering that it may cause flare ups associated with the bacteria, tissue and irrigating solutions that can be introduced into periapical tissues. Engine driven techniques seem to extrude smaller amounts of debris which can probably be attributed to the rotary motion which tends to direct debris towards the orifice. Authors warn that caution should be used when extrapolating this study to clinical situations because no attempt was made to simulate the presence of vital pulps or periapical tissues, both of which may restrict apical extrusion in vivo.

 

 

To Top

 

Week of October 15, 2001

 

 

 

Title: Clinical performance of three endodontic sealers

Authors: Waltimo, Tuomas M.T. et al.

Journal: O.O.O., July 2001 Pgs: 89-92

Reviewed by: Andy Schoelch, D.D.S.

Purpose: To compare the clinical and radiographic treatment outcomes of 3 different sealers used in endodontic therapy and evaluate the effect of incorporated calcium hydroxide on the outcome of therapy.

Materials and Methods: Two hundred and four teeth underwent a standardized endodontic treatment regimen and were assigned to 1 of three groups at the time of root filling: (1) group PS, teeth filled with GP and Procosol sealer; (2) group CR, teeth filled with GP and CRCS sealer; and (3) group SA, teeth filled with GP and Sealapex sealer.
The results of the treatment were assessed yearly for up to 4 years by clinical and radiographic (PAI scores) analysis. The ridit statistic (r) was used to compare PAI scores among the groups.

  • SealapexSalicylate, Sulfonamide, Calcium hydroxide
  • Procosol – ZOE, Rosin
  • CRCS – ZOE, Calcium hydroxide

PAI index – range of 1 to 5:         1 = radiographically healthy apex         2 to 5 = increasing severity of AP

Results: During the first year after filling, the mean ridit value decreased in all test groups meaning the PAI index decreased (Change in r value, SA = .20, PS = .05, CR = .03).

After 2 years, teeth in group SA had slightly better PA conditions than group CR and PS. The difference was statistically significant at the P = .01 level. By years 3 and 4, no significant difference among the groups was present.

Conclusion: The overall influence of the sealer on treatment outcome was small. Root fillings with salicylate resin that contain calcium hydroxide may ensure more rapid healing of apical periodontitis or operative trauma, but the results after 3 and 4 years were statistically indistinguishable from those obtained by using ZOE-based sealers with or without calcium hydroxide.

 

 


Title:  A comparative evaluation of the diagnostic efficacy of film and digital sensors for detection of simulated periapical lesions

Author:  Wallace JA, Nair MK, Colaco MF, Kapa SF

Journal: Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 2001; 92:93-7

Reviewer:  Joe Simoneaux, D.D.S.

Purpose: To compare the diagnostic efficacy of conventional radiographic imaging to direct digital imaging using a charge-coupled device and a photostimulable phosphor-based sensor for detection of simulated periapical lesions.

Materials & Methods:

Four defleshed cadaver mandibles were invested in acrylic resin and sectioned to obtain the second premolar, first molar and second molar, separately, providing 24 samples in total. Images of the specimens were acquired before lesion induction to serve as controls. The following imaging systems were used: Ektaspeed Plus film, Soredex Digora system with PSP-based sensor and the Schick Computed Dental Radiography system with a #2 CCD-based sensor. A Gendex GX 770 x-ray source was used with constant kVp, mA and exposure time. Each image sensor was maintained in position with a precision instrument, Rinn XCP, to ensure standardized projection geometry for all systems.

Lesions were produced in the apical region by using round burs #1, 2, 4 & 6. A 2-cm thick tissue-equivalent material was used to simulate attenuation and scattering of the soft tissue of the face. Images were again obtained of the samples. To ensure optimal visualization of the lesion, the digital images were subsequently enhanced through manipulation of the brightness and contrast.

A panel of four observers, a periodontist, two endodontists and a general dentist, all trained in interpretation of these images, was asked to express subjective certainty of the presence or absence of a lesion using a 1-5 confidence rating scale. Each observer was allowed the option to further manipulate the image using brightness and contrast controls. The percent of correct response (PCR) was computed on the basis of imaging modality, observer and lesion size.

Results: Conventional film had the highest PCR, followed by PSP and CCD-based systems. The PCR was high for all imaging modalities (film: 97%, CCD: 74%, PSP: 73%) when no lesion was present. When small lesions were present, PCR values fell more for CCD images than PSP images. No statistical difference was noted between the digital imaging modalities.

Discussion:  The better performance of film-based images indicates that observers were biased toward this imaging system because of familiarity and the fact that magnification can enhance resolution. On the other hand, the lack of familiarity with digital imaging and lack of experience with image enhancement resulted in poorer performance. Resolution of digital images is another factor that can affect diagnosis. It depends on the pixel size of the sensor and the resolving power of the monitor on which the images are displayed.

 


Title:  Comparison between PAI and quantitative digital radiographic assessment of apical healing after endodontic treatment

Author: E. Olutayo Delano, et al.

Journal: OOO,108. July 2001

Reviewer:  Mark Wang, DMD, MS.

Purpose: To compare both subjective (Periapical Index, PAI) and objective (densitometric) radiographic evaluation of healing after endodontic treatment for apical periodontitis.

Material & Methods:

  • Standardized radiographs of 193 teeth taken at baseline (immediately after endodontic treatment) and at 1, 4, 12, 26, and 52 weeks were evaluated.
  • Consensus PAI scores obtained from 7 calibrated observers served as "true scores".
  • Densitometric estimates of periapical status were obtained from digitized radiographs as the ratio of mean gray value of an area of radiolucency (AR) to an adjacent and similar-sized normal (N) area (AR/N).
  • The selected regions of interest on baseline images were automatically superimposed on postoperative images.
  • All estimates of change were measured with respect to baseline.
  • The subtraction estimate was expressed as ARs-Ns.
  • Linear regression was used to analyze longitudinal changes against baseline and to assess the relationship of PAI and AR/N and of change in PAI with respect to baseline and Ars-Ns.

Results:

  • 556 PAI scores were generated, with 547 AR/N values and 444 subtraction estimates.
  • PAI, AR/N, and ARs-Ns demonstrated statistical significance for change (P<.05) starting at 12 weeks.
  • PAI was significantly correlated with AR/N (P<.0001), as was CHPAI with Ars-Ns (P<.024)

Conclusion:

  • The PAI and 2 densitometric estimates (AR/N and ARs-Ns) detected healing of apical periodontitis at 12 weeks after treatment.
  • No difference could be observed among the methods.

 

 

 

 

Title: The standardized-taper root canal preparation – Parts 1 to 6

Author: Buchanan et al.

Journal: Int. End J. 2000 (33) 516-529; Int. End J. 2001 (34) 63-71, 149-156, 157-164, 244-249, and 250-259

Submitted by: Paul Slusarz, D.M.D.

Purpose: This six part series introduced the concept and characteristics of variable taper instruments (Greater Taper   or  GT ) and illustrated the techniques used by Dr. Buchanan to instrument both large and small canals using these files.

Discussion: (Key Points)

Part 1. Concepts for Variably Tapered Shaping Instruments:

  • Canal preparation is difficult to practice and teach with traditional K-files and Gates Glidden drills.
  • Variable taper files are designed to offer the optimal preparation features of adequate (not excessive) coronal enlargement, full deep shape, and apical resistance form in a simple instrument sequence.
  • Variable taper technique is simple to master, and offers predictable cleaning and obturation outcomes, even in inexperienced hands.

Part 2. GT File Selection and Safe Handpiece-Driven File Use:

  • The standard GT file set comprises three instruments of 0.06, 0.08, and 0.10 taper. All are size 20 at the tip, and have a maximum diameter of 1mm.
  • Accessory GT files have a standard taper 0.12, and maximun diameter of 1.5mm. They are available in tip sizes 35, 50, and 70.
  • Large roots are lower canines, upper anterior, upper and lower single-rooted premolars, palatal roots of upper molars and distal roots of lower molars. They should be prepared with 0.10 GT or 0.12 accessory GT files.
  • Small roots are lower incisors, multirooted premolars, buccal roots of upper molars and mesial roots of lower molars. They should be prepared with 0.06 or 0.08 GT files.
  • All GT files should be used with light forces and at the correct spin speed.
  • GT files should be discarded after the equivalent of five root canal uses.

Part 3. GT File Techniques in Large Root Canals with Small Apical Diameters:

  • Large root canals with small apical diameters should be prepared to shaping objectives 0.08 or 0.10 taper.
  • Compacted pulp tissue causes many canal blockages. It should be removed early, and canals should be well lubricated.
  • Large root canals with small apical diameters should be prepared in crown-down sequence, with recapitulation of steps until the shaping objective is achieved.
  • Apical resistance form should always be confirmed before cone fit.
  • Canals should be exposed to sodium hypochlorite for at least 30 min. for effective cleaning.

Part 4. GT File Techniques in Large Root Canals with Large Apical Diameters:

  • Tapered apical preparations offer optimal resistance form for obturation.
  • Tapered apical preparations can be prepared in most roots with wide apices by extending GT files and GT accessory files to or through the apex.
  • Apices wider than 0.7mm should be repaired with MTA prior to filling.

Part 5. GT File Techniques in Small Root Canals:

  • Small root canals should be prepared to a shaping objective 0.08 or 0.06 taper.
  • Pulp tissue should be removed before preparation to prevent compaction and blockage.
  • Preparation follows in a crown-down sequence, and may occasionally require the use of small Profiles.
  • Final apical shaping is easily achieved when root length is reached.

Part 6. GT File Techniques in Abruptly Curved Canals:

  • Root canals do not calcify apically.
  • File progress is prevented by pulp tissue, abrupt curvatures or ledging.
  • Loose resistance to the passage of a size 10 file shows the canals that require instrument pre-bending. This test should be repeated at intervals during the preparation.
  • Even NiTi GT files can be pre-bent for use in abrupt curves.
  • Gutta percha cones can be pre-bent after chilling.

 

 


Title: Letters To Editor

Journal: Int. End J. 2001 34(5) 411-413

Submitted by: Paul Slusarz, D.M.D.

Purpose: This was a response to the six part series on variable taper instruments (GT or Greater Taper) submitted by Dr. Buchanan.

Discussion:

Letter from Dr. D. Ricucci:

  • The articles do not seem to have been subjected to the peer review process.
  • Specific endodontic instruments were advertised without a disclaimer.
  • The methodology expresses controversial and unsubstantiated claims of superiority.
  • All valid prognostic studies – with no exception – demonstrate that placing endodontic materials beyond the apical foramen considerably reduces success (Strindberg 1956, Molven 1976, Kerekes & Tronstad 1979, Bergenholtz et al. 1979, Kerekes et al 1980, Swartz et al. 1983, Sjogren et al. 1990, Smith et al. 1993, Friedman et al. 1995, Seltzer 1999)
  • Literature searches do not support the filling of non-cleaned lateral canals and apical ramifications. On the contrary, histological observations show that pushing material into such canals causes tissue destruction, inflammation and foreign body reactions.
  • Long-term follow-ups involving histological observations further demonstrate that although excess materials seems to disappear in radiographs, it remains for years and maintains adverse tissue responses.

Response from Dr. L. S. Buchanan:

  • After reviewing the literature by Dr. Ricucci, a different interpretation was made. The apical stop preparation in these studies was less than predictable. In those studies showing lower success rates in overfilled cases, an overfill represents not an obturation failure but a shaping failure.
  • With the technique of preparing an apical stop, an overfill usually equates with a length determination error and the common result is and apically lacerated root canal terminus (plenty of justification for failure).
  • Sjogren et al. (1997) reported that when procedures were carried out by experienced dentists (better cleaning and shaping) the success rate with overfills was 100% regardless of the culture results. They also showed that success in shortfilled cases required a negative culture.
  • Therefore, in his opinion, filling at least the whole root canal may grant a higher success rate than deserved, and surplus-filling material is coincidental to the real cause of these failures – poor shaping and cleaning.

Comments from the Editor, Professor Paul Dummer:

  • The series of articles authored by Dr. Buchanan were the first to be published in the new Clinical Section of the journal.
  • They were not in fact peer reviewed.
  • In the future, all of these clinical articles will carry a very clear disclaimer that whilst clinical articles are subjected to review, the opinions expressed, unless specifically indicated, are those of the author(s).

 

 

To Top

 

Week of October 22, 2001

 

 


Title: microscopic Diagnosis and treatment of a mandibular second premolar with four canals

Author: Al-Fouzan

Journal: Inter. Endo. J.: 34, 406-410, 2001

Reviewer: Pranav Vohra, D.M.D.

Purpose: To report the case of a mandibular second premolar with four distinct canals.

Discussion: According to the author the most frequent reason for endodontic failure is the practitioner’s inability to locate all the canals in a tooth and thus, the incomplete instrumentation leading to failure. 
- The case reported is that of a 34 year old AA male with a non-contributory medical history and a CC of ‘pain with hot and cold food and drinks'.
- Clinical exam reveals a carious lesion involving the pulp on tooth  # 21.
- Testing shows the tooth to be vital and a diagnosis of symptomatic pulpitis.
- Radiographic exam shows a widened PDL and two separate canals.
- During treatment, exploration with #8 K-files and microscopic investigation revealed two separate mesial canals (MB, ML) and one distal canal, which bifurcated mid-root.
- Treatment was carried out in two visits w/out intra-canal medicaments and all four canals after instrumentation using step-back technique to size 30 were obturated using lateral condensation with GP and AH-26 sealer.

Clinical Tips:  The author recommends several key indicators for practitioners' to pay attention to which teeth may indicate presence of three or four canals:

    1. Knowledge of basic root anatomy and pre-op radiographic exam would reveal changes in root shape, root position, and relative root outline.
    2. Clinically, when the pulp chamber does not appear to be aligned in the classic bucco-lingual pattern, or the configuration of the pulp chamber deviates from the normal and is too large mesio-distally, or triangular in shape, then a third and fourth canal should be suspected.
    3. Tactile exam and exploring with a small #6 or #8 pre-curved k-file is recommended.
    4. The author stresses upon the use of a microscope in such cases.

 

 

 


Title: Enterococcus faecalis - a mechanism for its role in endodontic failure

Author:  Love, R.M.

Journal:  Int. Endod J.;34(5):399-405, 2001

Reviewer: Kimberly Pham, DMD

Purpose:  To identify a mechanism that would explain why cells of E. faecalis could survive within dentinal tubules and maintain the potential to penetrate dentinal tubules.

Materials &Methods:

  • Cells of S. gordonii DL1, S. mutans NG8, or E. faecalis JH2-2 were grown in brain heart infusion broth containing human serum for 56 days.
  • Non-carious unrestored human teeth with single root canals were prepared for invasion experiments. Roots were split along the long axis to produce 2 longitudinal root specimens with intact cementum from each root. These specimens were submerged in BHY medium containing bacterial cells for 14 days.
  • Under light microscope, tubule invasion index (TI) was determined by the number of tubules containing bacteria under x 400 magnification: 1-20 tubules infected (score 1); 21-50 tubules infected (score 2), and >50 tubules infected (score 3). The scores were then added and averaged. TI < 0.5 = nil invasion; 0.5-1.0 = mild invasion; 1.0-2.0 = mild to moderate; >2.0=moderate to heavy; >2.5= heavy.
  • Radioactively labeled bacterial cell suspension was incubated with prepared type I collagen suspension.

Results and Discussion:

  • Three bacteria grow and remain viable in human serum for a prolonged period demonstrates that oral bacteria are able to gain nourishment from tissue fluids from PDL and alveolar bone that bath the root.
  • Bacterial penetration of root dentin is enhanced when cementum is mechanically removed or area of external resorption. The invasion is heavy in cervical area of the root.
  • Some component(s) of serum affect the dentin invasion mechanism of S. mutans and S. gordonii but E. faecalis.
  • Love et al (1997) demonstrated that dentin invasion was associated with cell adherence to type I collagen and excess free collagen added to the solution competitively abrogated cell invasion.

ConclusionE. faecalis cells remain viable, and maintain the capability to invade dentinal tubules and adhere to collagen in the presence of human serum. This may explain why cells of E. faecalis within radicular dentinal tubules act as a pathogen in failed endodontically treated teeth and their periapical disease involvement.

 

 


TITLE: Treatment of replacement resorption with Emdogain – preliminary results after 10 months

AUTHOR: Andreas Filippi, Yango Pohl, Thomas von Arx

JOURNAL: Dental Traumatology: 17: 134-138, 2001

REVIEWER: Donna Salin,D.M.D.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the treatment of early stage replacement resorption with intentional replantation using Emdogain, a protein complex that may facilitate cementoblast repopulation of the denuded root surface.

Materials &Methods:

  • Eleven ankylosed teeth in 11 children and adolescents were included in the study, all with replacement resorption present at an early stage or affecting only a small area of the root.
  • These teeth were extracted, the root canal was treated extraorally and obturated by retrograde insertion of a cylindrical titanium post.
  • Emdogain was applied to the root surface and into the extraction socket with subsequent replantation of the tooth.
    • Emdogain, a protein complex, may induce the cementoblast repopulation of the denuded root surface and may have a combined effect upon migration and differentiation of mesenchymal stem cells.
  • Stabilization of the replanted tooth was secured for 10-14 days by means of a non-rigid bracket splint.

RESULTS: During a mean follow-up period of 6.3 months (3-10 months), no signs of recurrence of ankylosis were noted. The horizontally and vertically measured Periotest scores were identical to those obtained on the adjacent teeth. All teeth were functionally and clinically within normal limits. Two teeth had a slightly high percussion tone, but the horizontal as well as vertical Periotest scores were in a normal range. Radiographically, no pathologic findings were present.

DISCUSSION: Replacement resorption of teeth replanted after trauma in children and adolescents may result in localized disturbance of jaw growth. Therefore, these ankylosed teeth should be removed. The results of this study suggest that Emdogain may be considered as a treatment option for these cases, as it may prevent or delay replacement resorption of teeth, provided the ankylosis is detected at an early stage.

 

 


Title: Guidelines for evaluation and management of traumatic dental injuries

Journal: Dental Traumatol. 2001;17:1-4

Committee: M Flores, JO Andreasen, LK Bakland

Prepared by: Nima Dayani, DDS

The International Association of Dental Traumatology (IADT), conscious of the variation in treatment of dental trauma, has developed guidelines as a type of consensus statement. These guidelines reflect discussion among members of the IADT as well as review of the literature. Where data did not appear conclusive, recommendations were based on the consensus opinion of the IADT board members.

These guidelines will be published over the next few issues of the Dental Traumatology Journal. This issue contains guidelines for management of trauma in primary teeth. They are presented in the following two tables.

Table 1: Treatment guidelines for tooth and/or bone fractures in the primary dentition

 

Crown fracture

Crown-root fracture

Root fracture

Alveolar fracture

Uncomplicated

Complicated

Diagnosis
Clinical findings

Enamel fracture or Enamel-dentin (E/D) fracture

Same as E/D fracture, with pulp exposure

The coronal fragment is attached to the gingiva and mobile.  The pulp may or may not be exposed.
Minimal to moderate tooth displacement

Tooth is mobile and coronal fragment may be displaced

The tooth-containing segment is mobile and usually displaced.  Look for a step or discontinuity

Radiographic assessment and findings

Take one radiograph (B)
Evaluate size of pulp chamber and stage of root development and resorption

Take one radiograph (B)
Evaluate size of pulp chamber and stage of root development

Take one radiograph (B)

Take one radiograph (B)

Take one radiograph (B)

Treatment

Smooth sharp edges.
If possible the tooth can be restored with glass ionomer filling material or composite

Perform pulpotomy (formocresol + ZOE) or RCT or extract

Extract.  Do not be overzealous in an attempt to remove root fragments.

If displaced, extract only the coronal fragment.
The apical fragment should be left to be resorbed physiologically

Reposition the segment.
Splint to adjacent teeth for 3-4 weeks.
If needed to maintain stability splint for 2-3 weeks or extract.

Patient instructions

Soft diet for 10-14 days
Brush teeth with a soft toothbrush after each meal
Follow up (see Table 2)

(B) Periapical central angle (size 2, horizontal view).

Table 2: follow up schedule of acute dental trauma - primary dentition.

 

Uncomplicated
crown fracture

Complicated
crown fracture

Alveolar fracture

Root fracture

No displacement

Extraction

Time

 

 

 

 

 

1 week

 

 

 

 

 

2-3 weeks

 

 

 

S + C

 

3-4 weeks

C

C

S + C

 

 

6-8 weeks

 

 

C

C

 

6 months

 

C

C

 

 

1 year

 

C

C

C

C (*)

Each subsequent year until exfoliation

 

 

 

C

 

S = Splint removal
C = Clinical and radiographic exam
(*) = Radiographic monitoring until eruption of the permanent successors.

 

To Top

 

Week of October 29, 2001

 

 

 

Title: Cytotoxic evaluation of root canal filling materials on primary human oral fibroblast cultures and a permanent hamster cell line

Author: Kuo-Tai et al

Journal: JOE, Vol. 20, No. 9, pgs 571-573

Reviewed by: Andy Schoelch, D.D.S.

Purpose: To determine the cytocompatibility of three different extracts of root canal and to compare the cytotoxic response of these materials on two different primary human oral fibroblasts (derived from gingival and buccal mucosa) with one permanent hamster line.

Materials and methods:  Three root canal sealers were tested

  1. AH plus
  2. Canals
  3. N2

Three cells were tested:

  1. Buccal fibroblasts (Human)
  2. Gingival fibroblasts (Human)
  3. V79 – A permanent cell line from Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts

-Cytotoxicity was determined using an assay of tetrazolium bromide reduction

Results:  All sealers were found to be cytotoxic to all cell lines of the 1-day elute and 3-day elute

    • N2 was the most toxic root canal sealer among those tested in culture
    • N2 > AH plus = Canals

-V79 was more sensitive than primary oral fibroblasts

Conclusion:  It is necessary to continue to investigate endodontic material until some are found that fulfill all the properties of ideal root canal sealers.

 

 


Title: 
Cytotoxicity of intracanal bleaching agents on periodontal ligament cells in vitro

Author:  Kinomoto Y, Carnes D, Ebisu S

Journal: JOE 2001; 27(9):574-77

Reviewer:  Joe Simoneaux, D.D.S.

Purpose: To examine the cytotoxicity of intracanal bleaching agents, sodium perborate (SP) and hydrogen peroxide (HP), on human periodontal ligament cells in vitro.

Materials & Methods:

Human PDL tissues were obtained from freshly extracted teeth. PDL cells were cultured and grown to confluence on culture wells. Three bleaching agents evaluated were :

  • 30% hydrogen peroxide
  • 2 g/ml sodium perborate mixed with 30% H2O2
  • 2 g/ml sodium perborate mixed with Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium containing 4% fetal bovine serum

PDL cells in culture were mixed with differing concentrations of the bleaching solutions for a period of 24 or 72 hours. The lactic dehydrogenase activity assay, which is based on the measurement of LDH activity released from the cytoplasm of cells with plasma membrane damage, was used to quantitate cytotoxicity.

Results: Data indicate that cytotoxicity of bleaching agents was influenced both by concentration of the agents and length of the incubation time. Low cytotoxicity of the SP was confirmed. After 24 hours exposure, SP was less toxic to the PDL cells than HP. After 72 hours, there was no difference in the cytotoxicity of the two solutions. The SP and HP mixture caused the greatest toxicity upon PDL cells after both 24 and 72 hours.

Discussion:  The mixture of SP and HP has a cumulative bleaching effect due to the fact that when in contact with water, SP decomposes to form HP. However, the greater cytotoxic effect on PDL cells of the mixture may lead to adverse effects when used for nonvital tooth bleaching. Although, SP is considered to be a relatively safe bleaching agent, it was proven to be toxic to the cells of the PDL. The best way to accomplish safe, nonvital bleaching is to prevent penetration of the bleaching agent through the dentinal tubules by the use of protective barriers. The use of heat during bleaching procedures should also be avoided as it accelerated the breakdown of SP into HP.

 

 


Title:
Molecular detection of black pigmented bacteria in infections of endodontic origin

Author: Siqueira, J., Rocas, I., Cezar, J., et al

Journal: JOE 2001; 27(9):563-566

Reviewed by: M. Pallante, D.M.D.

Purpose: To use a sensitive PCR diagnostic assay to determine the prevalence of black pigmented anaerobic rods in samples taken from infections of endodontic origin.

Materials and Methods:

Fifty four single rooted teeth from adult patients (18-60), all of them having carious lesions and necrotic pulps were included in this study. Fifteen teeth were sensitive to percussion and 10 were diagnosed with acute periradicular abscesses. Other cases were asymptomatic. Periradicular bone loss was evident in all but 2 teeth. Samples were collected under aseptic techniques. DNA was extracted from samples using TSB-DMSO media. Oligonucleotide primers specific to the following bacterial species were prepared: P. endodontalis, P. gingivalis, P. intermedia, and P. Nigricans. PCR analysis was performed using standard techniques and reaction products were analyzed using gel electrophoresis.

Results:  PCR assay detected black pigmented anaerobes in 59.3% of examined teeth. They were detected in 9/15 teeth sensitive to percussion and in 8/10 of the abscess samples. P. endodontalis was found in 42.6%. P. gingivalis was found in 27.8%. P. nigrescens in 7.4%. P. intermedia in 5.6%. 12 of the cases showed more than one species. The breakdown is as follows:

  • P. endodontalis + P. gingivalis = 8
  • P. endodontalis + P. nigrescens = 3
  • P. endodontalis + P. intermedia = 2
  • P. gingivalis + P. intermedia =1
  • P. endodontalis + P. gingivalis + P. intermedia =1

80% of the abscessed teeth showed black pigmented species. P. endodontalis appeared in 70%. P. gingivalis (40%) P. intermedia (10%).

Discussion:
Black pigmented anaerobic rods are recognized oral pathogens. They possess some important virulence factors which may be involved in the pathogenesis of periradicular lesions. It has been suggested that bacterial synergism plays an important role in the infectivity of black pigmented bacteria. Given this fact, and the fact that Porphyromonas spp. were frequently detected in both symptomatic and asymptomatic teeth, it is possible that bacterial synergism can influence the virulence of these species.

 

 


Title:
Long-term bacterial leakage along obturated roots restored with temporary and adhesive fillings

Authors: C. R. Barthel et.al.

Reviewer: Alison Morrison, D.M.D.

Purpose: The aim of this in vitro study was to examine the bacteria tightness of root fillings combined with temporary filling materials versus core buildup materials as a coronal seal on a long-term basis. The authors also looked at the effectiveness of a wax in addition to the temporary seal.

Materials and Methods: The crowns of 130 extracted single-rooted teeth that had been stored for various times in a 20% ethanol solution were separated from their roots and discarded. The roots were then trimmed to an approximate length of 14mm. Standardized cavities (3mm X 2.5mm and 4mm deep) were prepared with a diamond bur simulating typical access preparations for endodontic treatment.

Each root was instrumented to a size #60 master file and was kept 1mm short of the apex. Step back technique and copious irrigation with 2.5% NaOCl were included in this experiment. Apical patency was checked with a #15 file. Each tooth was placed in the ultrasonic with a 5% aqueous solution of EDTA for 20 seconds to remove the smear layer. One hundred twenty of these roots were obturated with laterally condensed gutta-percha combined with AH26. The roots were randomly assigned to six groups.

The access cavities were sealed with one of the following: Clearfil, CoreRestore (a core buildup material), Ketac cement (a glass-ionomer cement), or resin-enforced zinc oxide-eugenol cement - IRM. Two experimental groups were filled with wax and glass ionomer or wax and IRM. Here the wax was placed on top of the root canal filling and the rest of the cavity was filled with the temporary filling material.

Five of the remaining roots were filled with AH26 and lateral condensation but without a coronal seal and two roots were left empty as positive controls. Three roots were filled with gutta-percha and AH26, and the apices were completely covered with sticky wax. These were used as negative controls. Roots were covered in sticky wax except for the coronal plane and the apical 1-2 mm. They were mounted to 15mm polyethylene tubes (top chamber). These were sterilized and sealed to glass vials (bottom chambers). Five to six mm of the root tips were hung into the sterile broth. Top chambers were inoculated with broth containing 0.25 mg streptomycin/ml and a streptomycin resistant Staphylococcus epidermidis at 10 colony forming units/ml. The bottom chambers were checked for turbidity first daily, then three times per week, then once every fourth week for a period of one year.

Results: Two samples had to be discarded due to a failure of the wax seal. All viability checks showed bacterial growth. The fluids from the samples with clear bottom chambers did not show any bacterial growth when incubated. Two bottom chamber samples stained positively for bacterial remnants. For the mean daily leakage there was no significant difference among the groups. At the end of one year, only three samples from the CoreRestore group and two samples from the Clearfil group resisted leakage. But again, no significant difference in the number of leaking samples could be seen among the groups. All negative control samples successfully prevented bacteria from corono-apical passage.

Discussion: This study design offers a worst-case scenario. If only a single microorganism had reached the bottom chamber it would only be a matter of time before the liquid turned turbid. Whereas in the human body one could assume that a single microorganism could be fought off by the bodies immune system. It should also be noted that, according to the authors, even bacterial cell walls could elicit and maintain an inflammatory response. S. epidermidis was chosen because it has been shown to penetrate along root fillings in previous studies.

IRM was chosen due to its frequent use as a temporary filling material. Clearfil and CoreRestore were chosen in an attempt to differentiate between adhesive materials and non-adhesive materials. In this study they failed too. It should be stressed that this study is looking at the long-term performance of these materials. Due to the fact that all negative control samples prevented bacterial leakage the idea that wax combined with either IRM or glass-ionomer may enhance the seal of access cavities. 

Conclusion: All examined materials might provide acceptable protection against bacterial leakage in the first four weeks, but in the long-term, Clearfil may be recommended as the material of choice. All samples showed bacterial leakage at one year and because of that, it is suggested to keep the interval between obturation and final restoration as brief as possible.

 

To Top


Temple University School of Dentistry. All contents copyright (C) 1996. All rights reserved.
Created: September 20, 2000 Revised: URL:

 

Roy H. Stevens, DDS, MS; Wanda Gordon, D.M.D. - Comments to author:

wgordon@dental.temple.edu

Questions or problems regarding this page? Please mail:

webmaster@dental.temple.edu