Department of Endodontology

Temple University

 

 

Current

December 04

December03

December02

 

 

 

November 05

November 04

November03

November02

November01

March01

December00

October 05

October 04

October03

October02

October01

February01

November00

September 05

September 04

September03

September02

September01

January01

October00

 

 

Week of December 3, 2001

 

 


Title: 
Prevention of the ingress of a known virulent bacterium into the root canal system by intracanal medicament

Author:  Roach, P.

Journal:  JOE. Nov 2001; 27 (11) : 657-660

Reviewed by: Kimberly Pham, D.M.D.

Purpose:  To investigate the efficacy of Ca(OH)2 , Ca(OH)2 points, Ca(OH)2 and camphorated paramonochlorophenol (CMCP), and 1% chlorhexidine (CHX) gel- to delay contamination of the root canal system after endodontic therapy has been initiated.

Materials & Methods:

  • 80 extracted caries-free, human maxillary anterior teeth were used.
  • Crowns were cut off to CEJ, leaving root length about 15 mm.
  • A 3mm deep reservoir was made in coronal portion of each canal.
  • Canals were instrumented with rotary instruments.
  • Intracanal medicaments were placed in each group of 15 roots as follow:

Grp A: Ca(OH)2/ methylcelulose paste

Grp B: Ca(OH)2 and CMCP

Grp C: 1% CHX gel

Grp D: Ca(OH)2 points

Positive controls : 10 roots with NO medicament

Negative controls: 10 roots sealed with Optibond Solo bonding agent, Endo Solo resin, and light cure composite core paste.

  • Each root was placed and sealed through an opening made on a rubber stopper.
  • This rubber stopper was placed and sealed onto a test tube that contained BHI broth, leaving 3mm root apex dipped in the broth.
  • This testing model (developed by Siqueira) was autoclaved at 121° C before use.
  • Sample of E. faecalis was sealed in the coronal reservoir.
  • The test system was incubated at 37° C aerobically.
  • Turbidity of BHI broth in test tube was measured over time period of 60 days.

Results:

  • Positive controls showed turbidity in broth in 3 days.
  • Negative controls showed NO turbidity throughout the experiment.
  • The mean number of days to contamination as indicate by turbidity in the closed system was: Grp A: 37, Grp B: 46, Grp C: 16, Grp D: 5

Conclusions:

  • In preventing contaminations of the root canal system during multiappointment endodontic treatment, and possibly improved healing, Ca(OH)2 may yield an increase in success of nonsurgical treatment.
  • This in vitro study was limited to one species of bacteria. Direct extrapolations to clinical conditions associated with bacterial complexity must be done with caution.

 

 

 


Title:
Ability of three root-end filling materials to prevent bacterial leakage.

Author: Siqueira et al.

Journal: JOE: 27(11): 673-75, November 2001.

Submitted by: Paul Slusarz, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate the ability of three materials – a resinous root canal sealer (Sealer 26) prepared in a thick consistency, a reinforced zinc oxide-eugenol cement (IRM), and a glass ionomer cement (Fuji IX) – in preventing bacterial leakage.

Materials & Methods:

  • Seventy intact, caries-free human cuspids with straight roots were selected for this study.
  • After initial radiographs, teeth were conventionally accessed and the coronal portions of the canals were flared with #3 and #4 Gates-Glidden burs.
  • To standardize the diameter, the apical foramen was enlarged and kept patent to a #40 file, and then preparation was completed using step-back of 1mm increments.
  • The apical 3mm of each root were removed and root-end preparations were created using diamond ultrasonic retrotips.
  • A #70 or #80 gutta-percha cone with a snug fit was placed 3mm from the apical opening and served as a matrix against which the root-end materials (IRM, Fuji IX, and Sealer 26) were condensed.
  • Five prepared teeth not retrofilled served as the positive controls, and another five teeth with intact crowns served as the negative controls.
  • In all experimental groups and control groups, no coronal sealing was done.
  • Retrofilled teeth and controls were then mounted in a glass-tube testing apparatus containing broth and a reservoir of saliva was attached to the coronal portion and was replenished every three days.
  • Testing time for leakage was 60 days, during which time the broth was checked on a daily basis for turbidity.

Results:

  • All specimens of the positive control group showed broth turbidity within one day of incubation and there was no evidence of broth turbidity after 60 days in the negative control group.
  • After 60 days, bacterial leakage was observed in all teeth of the Fuji IX group, and 95% of the IRM group.
  • 65% of the teeth retrofilled with sealer 26 showed leakage.
  • Sealer 26 was significantly more effective in preventing bacterial leakage than the other materials.
  • No difference was detected between Fuji IX and IRM.

Discussion:  Of the materials tested in the present study, Sealer 26 was the most effective in preventing bacterial leakage. Sealer 26 is a resinous cement similar to AH26, however it contains calcium hydroxide but not silver. Although it is recommended for use as a root filling material, the findings indicate that Sealer 26 has a potential to be used in retrofillings when it is prepared in a thicker consistency.

 

 

 


Title:  A comparison of apical sealing and extrusion between thermafil and lateral condensation techniques.

Author: Abarca AM, et al.

Journal: JOE 2001; 27:670-672

Reviewer:  Mark Wang, D.M.D.

Purpose: To compare thermafil and lateral condensation techniques with regard to apical sealing & extrusion.

Material & Methods:

  • 40 curved canals from 20 mesial roots of extracted human mandibular molars were used.
  • The canals were instrumented (Profile .04) using a crown-down technique and divided into 2 groups.
  • The experimental group was obturated using the Thermafil technique & the control group was obturated using the lateral technique.
  • Topseal sealer was used in both groups.
  • Apical extrusion was recorded; two molars were used as control teeth.
  • All specimens were stored in 100% humidity for 1 wk, coated with nail polish, except for the apical 2 mm, and were suspended in black India ink for 48 hr.
  • Molars were decalcified, rendered transparent, and linear dye penetration was measured .

Results:

  • Extrusion: there was no significant difference between the methods (p>0.05)

Table 1. Incidence (%) of apical extrusion between lateral condensation & Thermalfil technique

Rating

Thermafil

Lateral Condensation

0

60

75

1

15

15

2

25

10

0 rating - no sealer or GP at the foramen
1 rating - sealer and/or GP only at the foramen
2 rating - sealer and/or GP beyond the foramen

  • Apical leakage: there was no significant difference between the two groups (p>0.05)

Table 2. Mean leakage values of test groups

Group

Mean Dye Leakage (mm)

SD

Lateral condensation

0.770

2.241

Thermalfil

1.370

2.778

Conclusion:

  • The apical sealing and extrusion using Thermalfil are adequate and are not very different from lateral condensation.
  • The Thermalfil system is a satisfactory alternative to lateral condensation of GP for canals with curvatures between 20 & 40 degree.

 

 

To Top

 

Week of December 10, 2001

 

 


Title: 
Regulation of matrix metalloproteinase-2 production by cytokines and pharmacological agents in human pulp cell cultures

Journal: JOE: 27(11): 679-682, November 2001

Author: Chang, YC et al.

Prepared by: Lance Isaac, D.M.D.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of cytokines (IL-1 and TGF-b ). Protein synthesis inhibitor (cycloheximide (CD)), and protein kinase C (PKC) inhibitors (H7 and Go6976) on matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) production in human pulp cell cultures.

Materials and Methods: Human dental pulp cells were cultured from briefly impacted third molars from 3 healthy patients. The extracted teeth were placed in phosphate-buffered saline supplemented with penicillin, streptomycin and fungizone, on ice. The crowns and coronal third of the roots were cleaned, the teeth sectioned below the CEJ with HS bur and water, the pulp tissue removed aseptically, rinsed in HBSS, minced in Eagle’s medium supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum. Cultures were maintained at 37° C in a humidified atmosphere of 5% CO2 and 95% air. Confluent pulp cells were trypsinized, counted, and plated at a concentration of 5 x 104 cells in 60mm culture dish and allowed to reach confluence. Cells were cultured for 48h, at which time the medium was changed to a medium containing 10% FCS and appropriate concentrations of cytokines, protein synthesis inhibitor, and PKC inhibitors. The conditioned medium samples were collected on days 1, 2, 4, and 8 and stored at –20°C until assayed. Cell extracts were also assayed. Type IV collagenase (gelatinase) activity was assayed by zymography (SDS-PAGE).

Results/Discussion: The main gelatinase secreted by human pulp cells migrated at 72kDa and represented MMP-2. Minor gelatinolytic bands were also observed at 92kDa, corresponding to MMP-9. After an 8d culture period, CD>H7>TGF-b >Go6976 were found to depress MMP-2 production. IL-1 was found to elevate MMP-2 production. These cytokines and pharmacological agents had no effect on MMP-9 production or secretion. Overall, it seems that inflammatory cytokines stimulate the production of elevated levels of MMP-2, and MMP-2 might play a role in pulpal inflammation (MMPs are an important group of zinc enzymes responsible for degradation of ECM components such as collagen and proteoglycans). In addition, agents that target protein synthesis or the protein kinase C pathway in human pulp cells inhibit MMP-2 production, and such inhibition may contribute to therapeutic efficacy.

 

 

 


Title: Comparison of a warm gutta-percha obturation technique and lateral condensation

Author: Kenan Clinton and Van Himel

Journal: JOE: 27(11): 692, November 2001

Reviewer: Alison Morrison, D.M.D.

Purpose: To compare a warm gutta-percha obturation technique (Thermafil Plus) with lateral condensation for the ability to canal walls of a root canal system.

Materials and Methods: An extracted permanent maxillary central incisor was mounted in clear casting resin. Four alignment holes were drilled to assist in realigning the two halves after each fill. The root and block were sectioned mesiodistally through the center of the root canal. The tooth was instrumented to a visually obtained working length using an orifice shaper and nickel-titanium rotary files. During observation of the instrumentation, depressions and grooves were intentionally placed into the canal walls. The canal was obturated twenty times with each technique. Each case was evaluated and videotaped using the following evaluation criteria:

  • length of fill
  • replication to working length
  • replication of artificial depressions
  • quality of each artificial depression
  • voids

Results: A statistically significant difference (p< 0.005) was found between both techniques in all categories. Gutta-percha using the Thermafil technique was better able to flow into lateral spaces, had fewer voids, and replicated the surface of the root better. It also resulted in more apical extrusion than did lateral condensation.

Discussion: The success of any technique depends on the clinician’s knowledge of the technique, clinical skills, and ability to follow the manufacturer’s instructions. No technique alone should be judged as the cause of treatment failure. The results found that none of the Thermafil samples were short and that both techniques often resulted in apical extrusion which led the author to the question: Which (being long or being short in your fill) is more likely to contribute to long-term failure, benign materials such as sealer and gutta-percha out the canal or a small portion of the apical canal without material or possibly only sealer?

 

 

 

 



Title:
The operating microscope improves negotiation of second mesiobuccal canals in maxillary molars

Journal: JOE vol. 27, No. 11 November 2001

Author: Gorduysus, M. O.

Prepared By: Greg Dearing, D.M.D.

Purpose: Utilizing maxillary molars (1) Compare the ability of endodontists to locate and negotiate MB-2 canals in maxillary molars w/o magnification and w/ the operating microscope. (2) characterize the MB-2 canal with regard to prevelance, location, pathway and negotiability

Methods and Materials:

  • 45 extracted human maxillary 1st and 2nd   molars were used
  • Initially location and negotiation of MB-2 were attempted w/o magnification
  • Teeth in which the MB-2 was not located or could not be negotiated were further explored under operating microscope
  • Roots where MB-2 could not be negotiated even with the operating microscope were X-sectioned and inspected microscopically
  • Morphometric measurements were performed to map the location of the MB-2

Results:

  • W/O magnification an apparent MB-2 orifice was located in 42 teeth and the canal negotiated in 31 teeth (69%)
  • With the operating microscope one additional apparent MB-2 orifice was located, and 5 previously identified canals were negotiated (total = 80%)
  • The root X-sections confirmed the absence of MB-2 in all 9 teeth where it was not negotiated
  • Location of MB-2 varied randomly

Conclusion:

  • MB-2 can be negotiated in 80% of maxillary molars, although an orifice is apparent in 96 % of the teeth
  • Ability to negotiate MB-2 is facilitated by the operating microscope

 

 

To Top

 

Week of Deember 17, 2001

 

 

 

Title: Obturation of a retained primary mandibular second molar using mineral trioxide aggregate: A case report

Authors: O’Sullivan, S. M. and et. al.

Journal: JOE, vol. 27(11), November 2001, pg 703-705

Reviewed by: Andy Schoelch, DSS

Purpose: To present and follow a case using an alternate method of root canal obturation using MTA

Case Report:

  • 20 year old Caucasian male
  • History of pain on lower left side
  • Fractured amalgam with recurrent caries on tooth K
  • Caries excavated and temporized with IRM
  • Patient returned with pain and swelling
  • Dx: Necrotic pulp with chronic apical abscess
  • Emergency treatment performed by general dentist then referred to endodontist for completion
  • Mesial canals instrumented to 40 file, distal canals to 45 file
  • Obturation consisted of placing MTA into the canal and down packing with measured endodontic pluggers.
  • To control placement and manipulation of the MTA large paper points were used to blot the excess moisture from the cement and to assist in the vertical condensation of MTA.
  • 4 month follow up radiograph showed resolution in radiolucency at the apex of the mesial root. Patient was asymptomatic .

Conclusion:  This technique seemed to provide a biocompatible seal of the root canal system

 

 

 


Title:  In vitro longitudinal assessment of coronal discoloration from endodontic sealers

Authors: Parsons, J.R. and et. al.

Journal:  Journal of Endodontics, 27 (11):699, November 2001

Reviewed by:  Donna Salin, D.M.D.

Purpose: To evaluate, longitudinally, coronal discoloration from four sealers.

Materials and Methods:

  • Fifty intact human maxillary and mandibular single canal premolars free of caries, restorations, and coronal discoloration were sectioned in the coronal third of the root in a cross section.
  • The chamber contents were removed and instrumentation was via the canal.
    The following sealers were bulk introduced into the chamber:  AH26, Kerr Pulp Canal Sealer, Roths 801 (nonstaining), and Sealapex.
  • The apical access was sealed with white sticky wax and the teeth were maintained in a moist environment at 37° C.
  • Initial digital images of the teeth were made for base line comparison and subsequent images were at 1, 3, 9, and 12 month intervals.
  • The images were mixed and evaluated blindly by trained evaluators:  discoloration was recorded as either none, slight, or moderate based on the change from the initial image.

Results: Discoloration was induced by all four sealers, with slight to moderate visible changes that increased progressively through the 12 months.  For all groups, the discoloration was most evident in the cervical third of the crown and on the cervical root surface with minimal to no changes in the occlusal third.  There was slightly more discoloration with AH26 and Kerr Pulp Canal Sealer. 

Discussion: Predictably, AH26 and Kerr Pulp Canal Sealer caused slightly more discoloration (these are silver-containing sealers in which the silver corrodes to a gray-black, contributing to the staining).  The other two sealers tested did not contain silver; however, contain chemical ingredients, such as eugenol, that will oxidize and darken with time, leading to dentin staining.

In this study, no effort was made to remove the bulk of sealer placed in the pulp chamber.  In a clinical situation every effort should be taken to remove as much of the sealer as possible. 

 

 

 

 


Title: The effect of maintaining apical patency on periapical extrusion

Author: Lambrianidis, T. et al

Journal: JOE 27(11)696-698

Reviewed by: M. Pallante, D.M.D.

Purpose: In vitro study to evaluate the roles of the apical constriction and foramen and the use of a patency file on the apical extrusion of NaOCl and debris.

Materials and Methods:  Thirty-three freshly extracted human, single rooted maxillary incisors were used. Visual examination ensured the existence of a completely formed apex and straight roots. Teeth were stored at room temp. in 10% buffered formalin phosphate. Access cavities were prepared and a #10 hedstrom file was extended beyond the apical foramen to ensure patency. Teeth were mounted in holes in preweighed bottles and sealed with sticky wax. Irrigation solution used was 1% NaOCl.

Teeth were instrumented using a step-back technique to a #30 file to the apical constriction and a size 70 was 3.5 mm short of the working length. A patency file was not used deliberately throughout the root canal preparation. Irrigation was performed every second instrument by placing the needle tip 3 mm short of working length. A total of 10 ml NaOCl was used per tooth.

Extruded NaOCl and debris was weighed. Teeth were then held while the apical constriction was deliberately enlarged with a #30 file protruding 3 mm apically. Again, teeth were mounted in the bottles and a #55 file was worked to 1.5 mm short of working length to create a ledge. A #90 file was used coronally to the enlarged apical constriction. No patency filed was used and irrigation was identical to the first experiment. Extruded NaOCl and debris were weighed and the results were subjected to statistical analysis using the Student’s t test.

Results:  Mean weight of apical extruded debris was .404 g for instrumentation when the apical constriction was intact and .015 g when it was deliberately enlarged.

Discussion:  In this study, the amount of NaOCl and debris was measured because they are both responsible for periapical   inflammation and post-operative pain.

There was a significant difference in the amounts of extruded material before and after enlargement of the apical constriction, with greater extrusion when it remained intact. While this data appears paradoxical, the authors report that it may be due to the apical plug formation. This would be in accordance with Myers 1981 study that shows the least amount of extruded debris in teeth instrumented 1 mm short of the foramen as opposed to instrumenting to the foramen.

The literature shows no consensus on the consequences of apical plugging with autogenous dentin. When dentin chips are free of microorganisms, satisfactory healing has been observed. However, when they are contaminated, we see discouraging results.

The authors are careful to note that while in all the in vitro studies, like this one, a measurable amount of extruded debris was consistently observed, however in the only in vivo study performed, this was not the case due to the fact that periapical  tissue serves as a natural barrier preventing extrusion.

 

 

To Top


Temple University School of Dentistry. All contents copyright (C) 1996. All rights reserved.
Created: September 20, 2000 Revised: URL:

 

Roy H. Stevens, DDS, MS; Wanda Gordon, D.M.D. - Comments to author:

wgordon@dental.temple.edu

Questions or problems regarding this page? Please mail:

webmaster@dental.temple.edu